Growing Together: A Blueprint for Community Orchards in Perth and Kinross

Executive Summary

This report presents a comprehensive analysis of the multifaceted benefits of community orchards, with a specific focus on their potential to enhance community resilience, environmental health, and social wellbeing within Perth and Kinross. Drawing on extensive international research and a detailed examination of the local context, the report argues that community orchards represent a powerful, multi-faceted, and cost-effective strategy for achieving the region's existing policy goals.

Community orchards are far more than just collections of fruit trees; they are dynamic socio-ecological systems that deliver a suite of interconnected benefits. Environmentally, they function as biodiversity hotspots, designated as a UK Priority Habitat, and play a crucial role in climate change mitigation through carbon sequestration, urban cooling, and effective stormwater management. For public health, they provide direct access to nutritious, low-cost food, encourage physical activity, and offer restorative green spaces that significantly improve mental wellbeing. Socially, they are proven catalysts for community cohesion, acting as focal points where residents can collaborate, share skills, and build lasting social networks, thereby strengthening the very fabric of local life. Economically, they enhance local food security, offer opportunities for small-scale social enterprise, and contribute to a more resilient local food system.

Perth and Kinross is uniquely positioned to become a leader in the community orchard movement. The region possesses a rich horticultural heritage, particularly in the Carse of Gowrie, providing a deep cultural narrative for new projects. This is complemented by a vibrant existing network of community growing initiatives and a highly supportive policy landscape, including Perth & Kinross Council's Food Growing Strategy 2021 and the Climate Action Plan. Critically, the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015 provides the legal mechanism for communities to gain secure, long-term access to land.

This report demonstrates that investing in community orchards is not about launching a new, isolated initiative, but about deploying a highly efficient delivery mechanism for achieving existing, cross-departmental strategic goals. It offers a blueprint for action, providing practical guidance for community groups on governance and project management, and presenting a series of strategic recommendations for Perth & Kinross Council.

Principal Recommendations:

1. Strategic Integration: Formally integrate community orchards into key strategic planning documents, including the next Local Development Plan (LDP3), as a preferred form of green infrastructure.
2. Streamlined Land Access: Develop a simplified 'Community Asset Transfer for Food Growing' pathway to facilitate secure land tenure for community groups on council-owned land.
3. Dedicated Funding: Establish a dedicated "Perth & Kinross Orchard Fund" to provide small grants for both the establishment of new orchards and their crucial long-term maintenance and community engagement activities.
4. Network Development: Facilitate the creation of a Perth & Kinross Community Growing Network to foster peer support, skill-sharing, and resource collaboration among new and existing groups.
5. Championing Heritage: Partner with local experts to promote the planting of Scottish heritage and climate-resilient fruit varieties, preserving local biodiversity and ensuring the long-term success of the orchards.

By embracing the model outlined in this report, Perth and Kinross can cultivate not only fruit, but also stronger, healthier, and more resilient communities for generations to come.

Section 1: The Community Orchard Movement: A Global Perspective on a Local Solution

To understand the opportunity that community orchards present for Perth and Kinross, it is essential to first situate the concept within its broader historical and global context. The modern community orchard is not a novel invention but the revival of an ancient practice, re-imagined as a powerful response to contemporary social, environmental, and economic challenges. This section establishes the foundational, evidence-based case for community orchards, demonstrating that they are complex socio-ecological systems with profound and wide-ranging benefits.

1.1 From Ancient Roots to Modern Revival

The practice of cultivating fruit trees is deeply woven into the history of human settlement. Sophisticated fruit growing was practiced by Persians as early as 1500 BC, with knowledge later spreading to Europe through Greek and Roman conquests.¹ The Romans, in particular, took the cultivation of fruit trees seriously, bringing their advanced horticultural skills to Britain. Following the Roman retreat, it was the monasteries that became the custodians of this knowledge. From the 7th to the 15th centuries, monastic orders played a pivotal role in advancing fruit cultivation, viewing their orchards not only as a source of sustenance but also as places of spiritual significance and remembrance.¹ For centuries, orchards remained a common feature of the landscape, integral to both aristocratic estates and rural community life.¹

The contemporary community orchard movement, however, has more recent origins, born from a sense of loss and a desire to reclaim local identity. The movement began in England in the early 1990s, spearheaded by the arts and environmental group Common Ground.³ This revival was a direct and urgent response to the catastrophic decline of traditional orchards across the United Kingdom. Since 1945, the UK has lost an estimated 63% of its orchards, with some counties experiencing losses as high as 90% since the 1950s.⁴ This devastation was driven by post-war urban development, the intensification of agriculture, and the economic pressures of a globalised food market that favoured imported fruit.⁴ The primary impetus of the new movement was therefore one of conservation: to save the remaining old orchards and, crucially, to preserve the unique, local heritage fruit varieties they contained.³

This foundational goal reveals that the modern community orchard movement is fundamentally an act of resistance against both biological and cultural homogenization. It is not merely about planting trees, but about reclaiming and celebrating what Common Ground termed "local distinctiveness".³ In an era of what one Member of Parliament described as "cloned town centres, with their identical chains of shops," community orchards offer a tangible connection to a place's unique history and identity.⁵ The focus on heritage varieties—apples with names like 'Wareham Russet' or Perthshire's own 'Bloody Ploughman'—is about safeguarding living history and ensuring that the story of a place can be tasted as well as told. This act of valuing the local, the historical, and the particular over the generic and mass-produced provides a powerful, non-material motivation for community involvement, tapping into a deep well of civic pride and a desire to protect a shared heritage.

From its origins in England, the concept has spread and adapted globally. In North America, community orchards have been established in public parks, school grounds, and on reclaimed abandoned lots.⁷ In Europe, cities like Lisbon are creating public orchards to foster community and share skills.⁸ In each context, the model is tailored to local needs, but the core principles remain the same: to create shared, productive green spaces that are cared for by a community of people.⁸

1.2 The Orchard as an Ecosystem: Environmental Benefits

Community orchards are far more than community amenities; they are vital ecosystems that deliver a host of environmental services, contributing significantly to urban biodiversity and climate resilience. Their ecological value is so profound that traditional orchards have been designated as a UK Priority Habitat under the national Biodiversity Action Plan, recognising them as critical sites for conservation.⁹

The exceptional biodiversity of orchards stems from their structure as a "mosaic of different habitats".¹² They are ecologically complex, resembling mini parklands or woodland edges rather than monoculture plantations.¹⁰ Several unique features contribute to this richness:

• Early Senescence: Fruit trees are notable for being "early senescent," meaning they age relatively quickly and develop veteran features such as hollow trunks, rot holes, dead wood, and sap runs.⁹ These features, often seen as signs of decay in other contexts, are invaluable habitats for over 400 species of saproxylic (deadwood-dependent) invertebrates. They also provide nesting sites for birds like the Lesser Spotted Woodpecker and roosting spots for bats such as the Noctule.⁹
• A Calendar of Food Sources: From the first blossom in early spring to the last fallen fruit in winter, orchards provide a continuous source of food for wildlife. The blossom is a critical source of nectar and pollen for bees, hoverflies, and butterflies at a vital time of year.⁹ In autumn, overripe and windfall fruit feeds birds like fieldfares and redwings, as well as mammals such as badgers and hedgehogs.¹⁴
• Structural Diversity: Unlike dense woodlands, the widely spaced nature of orchard trees allows sunlight to penetrate to the ground. This fosters a species-rich grassland floor, which can support a colourful array of wildflowers like cowslips and orchids, in turn supporting a greater diversity of insects, small mammals, and birds.⁹

Beyond their role as biodiversity havens, orchards are powerful tools for climate change mitigation and adaptation, particularly in urban settings. They absorb and store atmospheric carbon, acting as effective carbon sinks that contribute to local and national net-zero goals.³ Research indicates that an average 15-tree community orchard can sequester approximately 29 tons of carbon over a 25-year period.¹⁷ They also combat the "urban heat island" effect, with tree canopies cooling city air by up to 10°F (approx. 5.5°C) through shading and evapotranspiration.¹⁵ Furthermore, orchards play a key role in sustainable water management. Their canopies intercept rainfall, while their root systems and the mulched ground beneath them act like a sponge, reducing stormwater runoff, preventing pollutants from entering waterways, and helping to recharge groundwater supplies.¹⁵

The management of these spaces, however, can reveal a productive tension between maximizing ecological value and meeting public aesthetic expectations. The very features that create the richest habitats—standing deadwood, rot holes, patches of uncut grass, and fallen fruit—can be perceived by an uninformed public as signs of neglect or poor maintenance. This presents both a challenge and a critical educational opportunity. A successful urban community orchard must therefore be more than a collection of trees; it must be a site of active ecological interpretation. Through clear signage explaining the purpose of a log pile, workshops on orchard wildlife, and consistent community communication, the project can reframe public perception. By doing so, the orchard transforms from a simple 'park' to be kept tidy into a 'working habitat' to be understood and appreciated, turning a potential management conflict into a powerful tool for deepening the community's ecological literacy.

1.3 The Fruits of Community: Social and Health Impacts

While the environmental benefits are profound, the most immediate and tangible impacts of community orchards are often on the health and wellbeing of the people they serve. They function as holistic public health interventions, addressing physical health, mental wellbeing, and social connection simultaneously.

Public Health and Nutrition

In an era of rising rates of obesity and diet-related illnesses, community orchards offer a direct and accessible solution.2 They provide fresh, healthy, and often organic fruit to communities, free of charge. This is particularly vital in urban areas that have become "food deserts," where quality fresh produce is difficult to find or afford.2 Access to locally grown fruit can improve diets and help combat conditions like diabetes.2 The fruit itself is nutritionally dense; for example, a single peach can provide up to 15% of the daily recommended value of vitamin C, while berries like the black chokeberry possess exceptionally high levels of antioxidants.18

Beyond nutrition, the activities associated with maintaining an orchard promote physical health. Gardening tasks such as digging, pruning, and harvesting provide regular, moderate exercise.¹⁹ Research has shown that just 30 minutes of gardening can burn a number of calories comparable to playing sports like badminton or practicing yoga, with regular physical activity proven to lower the risk of coronary heart disease and stroke.²⁰

Mental Health and Wellbeing

The positive impact of green spaces on mental health is well-documented, and orchards provide a particularly restorative environment. Exposure to nature and the act of gardening have been shown to reduce stress, anxiety, and mental fatigue.15 One study found that individuals who garden every day have wellbeing scores 6.6% higher and stress levels 4.2% lower than those who do not garden at all.20 Orchards can serve as tranquil places for quiet contemplation, offering a retreat from the pressures of urban life.3 The therapeutic value of these spaces is increasingly recognized, with studies showing that patients in hospitals with views of trees heal faster and with fewer complications.15 This has led to the development of specialized care facilities that incorporate orchard-like settings to support residents with mental health challenges or dementia.22

Education and Skill Development

Community orchards are invaluable outdoor classrooms. For many urban children, fruit comes from a supermarket shelf, disconnected from the seasons or the soil.5 Orchards provide a direct, hands-on opportunity to learn where food comes from, reconnecting people with the natural cycles of production.8 They are also vital hubs for skill-sharing and intergenerational learning. They offer a practical setting for training in traditional horticultural skills such as pruning, grafting, organic pest control, and preserving the harvest.2 This sharing of knowledge, whether in formal workshops or informal conversations over a shared task, builds individual confidence and community capacity.2

The following table provides a consolidated overview of the holistic benefits that community orchards deliver, underscoring their value as a multi-objective policy tool capable of addressing numerous strategic goals simultaneously.

Table 1: The Holistic Benefits of Community Orchards

1.4 Cultivating Local Economies

While community orchards are explicitly non-profit ventures, they generate significant economic value and contribute to the development of more resilient local food systems.⁸ Their primary economic contribution is to food security and food sovereignty. In a time of rising food costs and supply chain vulnerabilities, orchards provide a reliable, hyperlocal source of nutritious food at negligible cost to the consumer.⁴ By making fresh fruit freely available, they directly address food insecurity, with many projects formally partnering with local food banks to distribute their harvest to those most in need.³ This strengthens community resilience by localising a portion of the food supply, reducing food miles, and giving communities more control over their food sources.³³

Although not their main purpose, many community orchards develop small-scale social enterprise activities to generate income for their own sustainability.⁸ A common model involves hosting community harvesting and apple pressing days, where the resulting juice or cider can be sold to cover orchard costs.³² Others may sell surplus fruit, jams, or other preserves at local markets or community events.¹⁵ In some instances, these projects can evolve into significant local enterprises. The Community Orchard in Fort Dodge, Iowa, for example, grew from a small planting into a destination featuring a café, a boutique shop, and other attractions, demonstrating the potential for agro-tourism.³⁶

These activities are part of a broader contribution to strengthening local food systems. Research on the economic impact of local food demonstrates that it connects communities with producers and adds significant value to the regional economy.³³ Community orchards are a tangible and highly visible form of urban agriculture that can help build these connections, fostering a culture that values locally produced goods and supporting a more sustainable and equitable food system for all.³⁴

Section 2: The Perth and Kinross Opportunity: A Fertile Ground for Growth

The global evidence for the benefits of community orchards is compelling, but their successful implementation depends on a supportive local context. Perth and Kinross is not just a suitable location for such initiatives; it is an ideal one. The region is uniquely positioned to become a leader in the community orchard movement, possessing a rare combination of rich horticultural heritage, a vibrant and active community growing scene, and a progressive and enabling policy landscape. This section analyses these local assets, arguing that Perth and Kinross has all the necessary ingredients to cultivate a thriving network of community orchards.

2.1 A Rich Heritage of Fruit

The roots of fruit growing in Perth and Kinross run deep, providing a powerful cultural narrative that new community projects can draw upon for inspiration and identity. The Tayside region, and particularly the fertile Carse of Gowrie, has been renowned for its apple, pear, and plum orchards for centuries, with a history stretching back to the monastic granges of the 12th century.¹⁰ This long tradition has given rise to a unique portfolio of local heritage fruit varieties, which are living artifacts of the region's agricultural history.

Varieties such as the 'Bloody Ploughman' apple, which legend says sprang from the heart of a ploughman shot for scrumping in the Carse of Gowrie, are not just fruits but stories embedded in the landscape.³⁹ Others, like 'Lass o'Gowrie', 'Tower of Glamis', and the 'James Grieve' apple from Edinburgh, represent a precious genetic and cultural inheritance.¹⁰ The existence of specialist nurseries in Scotland, such as Scottish Fruit Trees, which actively propagate and supply these heritage varieties, provides a crucial resource for community groups wishing to plant trees that are both historically significant and well-suited to the local climate.³⁹

However, this rich heritage is under threat. In line with national trends, the Tayside region has experienced a significant decline in its traditional orchards. A survey of 51 historically documented orchards found that 28 no longer exist, and of those remaining, only a handful retain significant value.¹⁰ This narrative of loss creates a compelling and urgent case for community-led conservation projects. By planting and restoring orchards, communities in Perth and Kinross can actively participate in safeguarding their local heritage, mirroring the original impetus of the UK-wide movement and creating projects with deep local meaning and resonance.

2.2 The Current Landscape: Existing Initiatives and Key Actors

Perth and Kinross is not starting from scratch. The region already boasts a dynamic and growing network of community-led food projects, providing a strong foundation upon which a more extensive orchard network can be built. There are over 30 existing community gardens, allotments, and orchards spread throughout the area, supported by a proactive council and dedicated third-sector organisations.²

Several flagship projects demonstrate the potential and diversity of community growing in the region:

• The Comrie Community Orchard, located at the historic Cultybraggan Camp, is a prime example of a successful, multi-funded project. Managed by the Comrie Development Trust's Orchard Working Group, it hosts regular work days, community harvesting events, and a popular annual Apple Day. The group generates income for its own sustainability by producing and selling juice and cider, showcasing a viable social enterprise model.³²
• Rewilding Denmarkfield, near Perth, integrates a community orchard with 49 allotment plots and a newly built community hub. This project is a centre for community engagement, hosting numerous nature-based events, workshops, and volunteer sessions focused on biodiversity and ecological restoration.⁴³
• The Milnathort and Kinross Allotments Association, founded in 2012, operates as a Scottish Charitable Incorporated Organisation (SCIO). It manages 37 allotments, a community garden, and an orchard, providing a robust and replicable model for community governance and management.⁴⁴

Beyond these, a network of smaller but equally important initiatives exists, including the Alyth Community Orchards, The Kinross Potager Garden, and Horner's Plot in Perth.⁴⁶ This existing landscape of active groups creates a supportive ecosystem for new projects, offering a wealth of local knowledge, experience, and potential for peer-to-peer mentoring.

This grassroots activity is underpinned by a crucial support infrastructure. Perth & Kinross Council's Community Greenspace team actively supports over 20 of these growing groups, providing advice, training, and the loan of tools and equipment.⁴⁶ The Council also maintains a "Food Growing Storymap," an online resource that helps connect residents with existing projects and opportunities.⁴² This is complemented by third-sector organisations like the Perthshire Seed Library, a partnership that promotes seed sovereignty and knowledge sharing among local gardeners ⁴⁷, and the Tayside Biodiversity Partnership, which offers expert advice on creating wildlife-friendly habitats.⁴⁸ This combination of on-the-ground action and institutional support makes Perth and Kinross an exceptionally fertile ground for the expansion of community orchards.

2.3 Policy and Support Frameworks: The Enablers of Growth

The potential for community orchards in Perth and Kinross is powerfully reinforced by a progressive and aligned policy environment at both the local and national level. The Council has put in place strategic documents that not only permit but actively encourage the kind of community-led environmental action that orchards represent, while Scottish legislation provides the legal tools necessary to turn these aspirations into reality.

At the heart of the local policy framework is the Perth & Kinross Council Food Growing Strategy 2021. Titled "Growing Together," its explicit vision is to create opportunities for people to grow their own food in order to "promote healthy, sociable and sustainable lifestyles".⁴⁸ The strategy specifically identifies community orchards and woodlands as a key type of community growing space and commits the Council to supporting their development by helping to identify suitable land and fostering knowledge-sharing networks.⁴⁸ This document provides a clear and direct policy mandate for the expansion of community orchards across the region.

This is further strengthened by the Perth & Kinross Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan, which sets out the route map to a "net zero carbon, and climate resilient, Perth and Kinross".⁵⁰ The plan's core principles include enhancing biodiversity, empowering communities to take climate action, and transforming land use to sequester more carbon.⁵⁰ As established in Section 1, community orchards deliver directly on every one of these objectives, making them a perfect fit for the Council's climate action agenda.

The critical enabling tool that connects these local ambitions with on-the-ground action is the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015. Part 5 of this landmark legislation establishes the Community Asset Transfer (CAT) process, which provides a formal right for community bodies to request to buy, lease, or otherwise manage land and buildings owned by public authorities.⁵² This is the key legal mechanism that can provide community orchard groups with the long-term, secure land tenure that is essential for a perennial project like an orchard. Successful CATs for community woodlands and food growing areas are already taking place in Scotland, demonstrating the viability of this route.⁵⁴ National charities like The Orchard Project have identified the Act as a uniquely progressive piece of legislation that offers a tangible pathway for establishing community orchards as protected, community-managed 'commons'.⁵⁵

The synergy between these supportive local strategies and this powerful national legislation creates an exceptional opportunity. However, a common challenge in public administration is the "implementation gap" that can exist between high-level strategic goals and tangible, on-the-ground projects. Local authorities often have numerous strategies—for food, climate, economy, and culture—that can operate in parallel policy silos. Community orchards offer a uniquely effective way to bridge this gap. They are not a 'silver bullet' solution, but they can be considered 'silver buckshot': a single, community-led, and relatively low-cost intervention that simultaneously addresses multiple strategic objectives across different departments. By championing community orchards, Perth & Kinross Council would not be adding a new initiative to its workload, but rather deploying a highly efficient delivery mechanism for achieving its existing, cross-cutting goals. This reframes the proposition from an orchard being "a nice thing to have" to it being "a strategic tool we should be actively deploying" to build a healthier, greener, and more connected Perth and Kinross.

Section 3: Weaving the Community Fabric: How Orchards Build Social Cohesion

The assertion that community orchards build a "sense of community" is central to their appeal, yet this statement often remains a vague platitude. To fully grasp their value, it is necessary to move beyond simple claims and analyse the specific, observable mechanisms through which these green spaces foster social cohesion. Drawing on social science research into urban green spaces and case studies of successful orchard projects, this section deconstructs how orchards function as powerful engines of community building, weaving together the social fabric of the neighbourhoods they inhabit.

3.1 Mechanisms of Connection: The Social Science of Orchards

Urban green spaces are not passive backdrops for social life; they are active agents in its creation. Research has identified four primary mechanisms through which they enhance community cohesion, all of which are exemplified by the community orchard model.²¹

First, they function as social arenas. As free, accessible, and inclusive public amenities, orchards provide a neutral "third space"—distinct from home and work—where people from diverse social, economic, and cultural backgrounds can interact.²¹ These informal, often cursory interactions are vital for building the "weak ties" between acquaintances that form the bedrock of a resilient social network and a broad sense of community.⁵⁶ Studies have shown that familiarity with local green spaces encourages more frequent and positive interactions between people of different ethnic groups, breaking down social barriers.⁵⁷

Second, they foster shared purpose and collective efficacy. The process of creating and maintaining an orchard requires collaborative action towards a visible, long-term goal.¹⁹ This shared work—digging, planting, weeding, pruning—builds bonds and a sense of mutual reliance. Crucially, it cultivates what sociologists term "collective efficacy": the shared belief that a community can work together to solve problems and bring about positive change.⁵⁶ This is powerfully demonstrated in case studies where communities have come together to transform neglected or anti-social spaces into thriving orchards, instilling a lasting sense of shared achievement.¹⁹

Third, they are incubators of social capital and trust. Volunteering and participating in community projects are common indicators of social cohesion, directly linked to the development of reciprocity and trust within a neighbourhood.²⁸ A national survey of UK community orchards found that one of their primary benefits is their ability to foster safe, trusting, and bonded communities.²⁸ The cycle of communal effort (caring for the trees) leading to a communal reward (sharing the harvest) is a powerful process that bonds people to one another and to their locality.²⁸

Finally, they cultivate a deep sense of place and ownership. The physical act of planting a tree and nurturing it over many years creates a profound connection between individuals and their local environment.²⁹ This "place attachment" is a cornerstone of social cohesion. The orchard becomes a symbol of the community's identity and a source of collective pride, enhancing the quality of the neighbourhood for all residents, even those not directly involved in its care.²⁹ This sense of ownership is a powerful motivator for stewardship and can be a key factor in the long-term success and protection of the space.³⁰

3.2 Catalysts for Engagement: From Planting Days to Harvest Festivals

The social benefits of community orchards do not arise spontaneously; they are generated and sustained through a calendar of structured and informal activities that intentionally bring people together. These events are the catalysts that transform a piece of land into a vibrant community hub.

The foundation of community engagement is the regular work day. These sessions, held for tasks like mulching, weeding, and pruning, provide the primary context for social interaction and collaborative work.¹⁹ They are the practical embodiment of the principle that "many hands make light work" and are where the strongest bonds between core volunteers are often forged.⁶²

However, it is the community celebrations that extend the orchard's reach to the wider neighbourhood, turning it into a focal point for local culture.³ Events such as:

• Apple Days or Harvest Festivals: These are often the flagship event of the year, bringing hundreds of local people together to celebrate the harvest with apple pressing, games, food, and music.²
• Wassailing: The revival of this ancient tradition of "blessing" the trees in winter is a popular and atmospheric event that connects the community to folklore and the changing seasons.²
• Blossom Festivals and Picnics: These simpler gatherings celebrate the beauty of the orchard and provide informal opportunities for socialising.⁷

Skill-sharing workshops on topics like pruning or grafting serve a dual purpose. While their primary goal is educational, they also function as social events that build a community of skilled and confident practitioners, empowering them to take on greater responsibility for the orchard's care.³

The 'Growing Orchard Communities' project in South Devon provides a powerful case study of these mechanisms in action at a regional scale. By linking 23 disparate orchard groups into a supportive network, the project amplified their individual efforts. It delivered 23 training workshops to over 300 participants and supported community events attended by more than 1,600 people.⁵⁸ The feedback from participants was a testament to the project's social impact. Volunteers reported that the opportunity to meet and share ideas with others who shared their passion was paramount, leading to a feeling of being part of something much bigger than their individual projects. One participant described how a creative event "really brought our community together in a way that I haven't felt before. It was creative, supportive and bonding".⁵⁸ This demonstrates that while individual orchards are valuable, a networked approach can exponentially increase their capacity to build social cohesion.

3.3 Overcoming Barriers to Inclusion: A Victory for the Commons

For a community orchard to succeed, it must navigate the inherent challenges of managing a shared public resource. The classic economic theory of the "Tragedy of the Commons" posits that any shared resource will inevitably be degraded by individual self-interest, leading to overuse or neglect.³⁰ In the context of an urban orchard, this can manifest as vandalism, theft of fruit, or damage to young trees, all of which are real risks, particularly on newly planted, open-access sites.³⁰

Successful community orchards defy this pessimistic theory by becoming well-managed 'commons'. They demonstrate that the solution is not privatisation or enclosure, but active and inclusive community management. This involves intentionally nurturing a "collective culture of practice" where shared norms and a sense of responsibility guide behaviour.³⁰ The very process of building and maintaining the orchard creates a virtuous, self-reinforcing cycle. The ongoing need for stewardship is not a burden to be minimized but is, in fact, the very engine of community building. The problem of long-term maintenance is solved by organising community workdays, which in turn become the primary mechanism for building social ties. The problem of potential vandalism is solved by fostering a deep sense of collective ownership through co-design and community events, which is itself a core component of social cohesion. The orchard is therefore not a static place where community happens, but a dynamic social process where the solutions to its practical challenges are the very activities that generate its primary social benefit.

A critical challenge within this process is ensuring that the orchard is a truly inclusive space. There is a recognised risk that community growing projects can sometimes attract only the "usual suspects"—more privileged, already engaged residents—thereby failing to reach the underserved communities who might benefit most.²⁸ Achieving genuine inclusivity requires a deliberate and proactive strategy. This includes prioritising the planting of new orchards in areas of high deprivation with limited access to nature.²⁸ It also means designing outreach and programming that actively addresses barriers faced by residents, such as financial and time poverty. Solutions can include offering free training courses that provide accredited skills and pathways to employment in the green sector, turning volunteering into a tangible opportunity for personal and economic development.⁶⁴ By consciously addressing these barriers, community orchards can move beyond being simply 'open' to being truly welcoming and empowering for all members of the community.

Section 4: A Blueprint for Implementation in Perth and Kinross

This final section translates the extensive evidence and analysis presented in this report into a practical, actionable blueprint for establishing and scaling a network of community orchards across Perth and Kinross. It provides clear guidance for community groups on the foundational steps of governance and project management, and offers a set of strategic recommendations for Perth & Kinross Council to create a supportive ecosystem for these initiatives to flourish.

4.1 Models for Success: Governance and Operations

The long-term sustainability of a community orchard depends heavily on the establishment of a robust and appropriate structure for its governance and operation. Community groups must make crucial early decisions about their legal form and their day-to-day management model.

Choosing a Legal Structure

The legal structure of a group determines its ability to own or lease land, handle finances, apply for funding, and protect its members from liability. For groups in Scotland, there are several options:

• Unincorporated Association: This is the simplest structure, requiring only a written constitution. It is suitable for small, informal groups with minimal financial activity and no plans to own assets or employ staff. However, its key drawback is that it is not a separate legal entity, meaning that committee members are personally liable for any debts or legal claims against the group.⁶⁵ This makes it unsuitable for any group intending to take on a lease or ownership of land via a Community Asset Transfer.
• Scottish Charitable Incorporated Organisation (SCIO): This is the most highly recommended structure for the majority of community orchard projects. Introduced in 2011, the SCIO is a legal form specifically designed for Scottish charities. It provides the benefits of incorporation—it is a legal entity that can own land, enter into contracts, and employ staff—while limiting the liability of its trustees.⁶⁵ As a registered charity, it can also access a wider range of grant funding. The process is regulated by the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator (OSCR). The successful Milnathort and Kinross Allotments Association provides an excellent local example of this model in action.⁴⁵
• Community Interest Company (CIC): A CIC is a legal form for social enterprises that use their profits for community benefit. While it offers limited liability, it cannot be a registered charity and is therefore ineligible for many grant funds.⁶⁶ It is best suited for orchard projects that have a significant and primary focus on generating income through commercial activities.

The following table provides a comparative overview to aid community groups in making this critical decision.

Table 3: Comparative Analysis of Legal Structures for Community Orchard Groups in Scotland

Operational Models

Once a legal structure is in place, the group can decide on its operational model. Common approaches include:

• Allotment-Linked Model: The orchard is a shared, communal asset within a larger allotment site. Maintenance can be organised through work parties that are a condition of plot membership. This model is already present in Perth and Kinross at sites like Rewilding Denmarkfield.⁸
• Membership Model: As seen in some Vancouver orchards, members pay a small annual fee to cover costs. This grants them a share of the harvest and carries the responsibility of participating in stewardship days.⁸
• Council Partnership / Public Park Model: The orchard is located in a publicly accessible space like a park or school grounds. The community group manages the orchard in close partnership with the landowner, typically the local council. This is a very common model and aligns well with the supportive role of the PKC Community Greenspace team.⁷

4.2 From Seed to Sapling: A Phased Implementation Plan

Establishing a community orchard is a long-term project that requires careful planning and execution. The following framework breaks the process down into four manageable phases, providing a practical roadmap for community groups in Perth and Kinross.

Table 4: Phased Implementation Framework for a New Community Orchard

4.3 Strategic Recommendations for Civic Prism and Perth & Kinross Council

To unlock the full potential of community orchards in the region, a supportive and proactive approach from local government is essential. The following recommendations outline key actions that Perth & Kinross Council can take to create a thriving ecosystem for community-led growing.

Recommendation 1: Integrate Community Orchards into Strategic Planning.

The Council should move beyond simply supporting individual projects and strategically embed community orchards into its core planning frameworks. This means explicitly recognizing community orchards in the next Local Development Plan (LDP3) 70 and the Perth City Development and Design Framework 71 as a preferred form of multi-functional green infrastructure. By designating them as a key tool for delivering on objectives related to climate resilience, biodiversity net gain, public health, and placemaking, the Council can create a clear policy imperative for their inclusion in new developments and public space regeneration projects.

Recommendation 2: Streamline and Promote Community Asset Transfer (CAT) for Food Growing.

Secure land tenure is the single biggest hurdle for community groups. The Council should build on the success of the Community Empowerment Act by creating a simplified and well-promoted 'CAT for Food Growing' pathway. This could involve providing a dedicated officer to guide groups through the process, developing template lease agreements suitable for orchard projects, and proactively identifying and publishing a list of under-utilised council-owned plots suitable for community cultivation, as committed to in the Food Growing Strategy.48 This would significantly lower the administrative barrier for community volunteers.

Recommendation 3: Establish a "Perth & Kinross Orchard Fund."

While national funding is available, a dedicated local fund would provide a vital catalyst for new projects. The Council should explore establishing a small grants fund, potentially in partnership with local businesses or modelled on successful initiatives like the Scotmid Community Orchard fund.69 This fund should be designed to cover not only the initial capital costs of trees and tools but also the crucial, often overlooked, ongoing costs of aftercare, volunteer training, insurance, and community events, which are critical for long-term sustainability.64

Recommendation 4: Foster a Perth & Kinross Community Growing Network.

The Council's Community Greenspace team is already doing excellent work supporting individual groups. This role could be formalised and expanded by facilitating a regional Community Growing Network. Inspired by the highly successful 'Growing Orchard Communities' model in South Devon 58, this network would connect new and established groups across Perth and Kinross. It could host annual skill-sharing events, facilitate the sharing of expensive equipment like apple presses, create a peer-mentoring program, and provide a unified voice for the community growing sector in the region, amplifying the impact of every individual project.

Recommendation 5: Champion Heritage and Climate Resilience.

The Council is in a unique position to promote best practices in planting. It should partner with local experts such as Scottish Fruit Trees 41 and the Tayside Biodiversity Partnership 10 to develop and disseminate a recommended planting list for community orchards in Perth and Kinross. This list should prioritise two key categories: local heritage varieties to preserve the region's unique genetic and cultural diversity, and modern, disease-resistant varieties that are proven to be resilient to Scotland's changing climate. By providing this guidance, the Council can help ensure that the orchards planted today will be healthy, productive, and valuable assets for generations to come.

Works cited

1. The Traditional Orchard Story | An Edible Landscape - WordPress.com, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://anediblelandscape.wordpress.com/the-traditional-orchard-story/
2. Benefits of orchards and fruit growing, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.theorchardproject.org.uk/guides_and_advice/benefits-of-orchards-and-fruit-growing/
3. Community Orchards - ATTRA – Sustainable Agriculture - NCAT, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://attra.ncat.org/publication/community-orchards/
4. Community Orchards and Food Security in Appalachia - The Research Repository @ WVU, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://researchrepository.wvu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1413&context=wvlr
5. Community Orchards - Hansard - UK Parliament, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2011-06-27/debates/11062748000001/CommunityOrchards
6. attra.ncat.org, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://attra.ncat.org/publication/community-orchards/#:~:text=In%20England%2C%20where%20the%20community%20orchard%20movement%20started%2C%20the%20first,even%20more%20by%20urban%20development.
7. Orchards 101, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://communityorchard.ca/orchards-101-2/
8. Community orchard - Wikipedia, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_orchard
9. Why are orchards priority habitats?, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.theorchardproject.org.uk/guides_and_advice/why-are-orchards-priority-habitats/
10. TRADITIONAL ORCHARDS IN TAYSIDE - Tayside Biodiversity ..., accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.taysidebiodiversity.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Traditional_Orchards_In_Tayside.pdf
11. Community orchards: How to guide - GOV.UK, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a78d20ae5274a2acd18a0ac/1973262.pdf
12. Orchard biodiversity - People's Trust for Endangered Species, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://ptes.org/campaigns/traditional-orchard-project/orchard-biodiversity/
13. Restoration of old orchards, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.theorchardproject.org.uk/guides_and_advice/restoration-of-old-orchards/
14. Orchard biodiversity tips - People's Trust for Endangered Species, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://ptes.org/campaigns/traditional-orchard-project/orchard-biodiversity/orchard-biodiversity-tips/
15. 22 Benefits of Trees - TreePeople, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://treepeople.org/22-benefits-of-trees/
16. The role of mixed orchards in carbon sequestration and climate change mitigation in a Mediterranean island environment - Frontiers, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/sustainable-food-systems/articles/10.3389/fsufs.2024.1457462/full
17. Micro-orchards for community connection and environmental justice - New Prairie Press, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://newprairiepress.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1084&context=ufss
18. Health Benefits of Orchard Fruits, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.phillyorchards.org/2019/01/22/health-benefits-of-orchard-fruits/
19. Community orchards case studies - GOV.UK, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a78ee8940f0b62b22cbdf0a/19732401.pdf
20. Why gardening makes us feel better – and how to make the most of it - RHS, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/health-and-wellbeing/articles/why-gardening-makes-us-feel-better
21. THE ROLE OF URBAN GREEN SPACES IN IMPROVING SOCIAL INCLUSION, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.irbnet.de/daten/iconda/CIB16580.pdf
22. Our Services - The Orchards Michigan, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://theorchardsmi.com/our-services
23. Orchards Highlands & Apple Tree, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://orchardshighlands.com/
24. Learn | Bloomington Community Orchard, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://bloomingtoncommunityorchard.org/site/learn/
25. Community Orchards, Redcar & Cleveland Borough Council | Local Government Association, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.local.gov.uk/case-studies/community-orchards-redcar-cleveland-borough-council
26. Community Gardents how to, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://cih.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/Community-Orchards-how-to-print-out_12.4.2017.docx
27. Orchard systems offer low-hanging fruit for low-carbon, biodiversity ..., accessed on August 8, 2025, https://academic.oup.com/bioscience/advance-article/doi/10.1093/biosci/biae140/7997959
28. British Community Orchards: sources of food, history and social connection, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.slowfood.org.uk/2022/09/03/british-community-orchards-sources-of-food-history-and-social-connection/
29. (PDF) Community gardening and social cohesion: different designs, different motivations, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/283616197_Community_gardening_and_social_cohesion_different_designs_different_motivations
30. Community Orchards - Open or Closed?, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.theorchardproject.org.uk/blog/community-orchards-open-or-closed/
31. Lawrence Fruit Tree Project | Sunrise Project KS, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.sunriseprojectks.org/lftp
32. Community Orchard - Cultybraggan Camp, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.cultybraggancamp.uk/community-orchard
33. Central Oregon Local Food System, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.coic.org/community-development/food-systems/
34. The Giving Grove Orchard Project - Food Well Alliance, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.foodwellalliance.org/orchard-project
35. Community Orchard Project | North Dakota Department of Agriculture, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.ndda.nd.gov/divisions/business-marketing-information/local-foods/community-orchard-project
36. The Community Orchard | Fort Dodge, Iowa, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.traveliowa.com/places/the-community-orchard/9783/
37. About Us - Community Orchard, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.communityorchard.com/our-story
38. Urban Fruit for Urban Communities | Home - USDA, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.usda.gov/about-usda/news/blog/urban-fruit-urban-communities
39. Stocklist | Scottish Heritage Fruit Trees | Scotland, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.scottishfruittrees.com/heritage-varieties
40. Scottish Apple Collection | Frank P Matthews Fruit Trees, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.frankpmatthews.com/catalogue/tree-collections/scottish-apple-collection/
41. Scottish Heritage Fruit Trees | Scotland Orchard experts, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.scottishfruittrees.com/
42. Allotments and Growing Spaces - Perth & Kinross Council, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/15330/Allotments-and-Growing-Spaces
43. Community - Rewilding Denmarkfield, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.rewildingdenmarkfield.co.uk/community
44. Milnathort and Kinross Allotments Association - Perth and Kinross Health and Social Care Partnership - Your Community PK, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.yourcommunitypk.org/listing/milnathort-and-kinross-allotments-association/
45. Milnathort and Kinross Allotments Association Logo, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.milnathortandkinrossallotments.org/
46. Volunteering with community greenspace - Perth & Kinross Council, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/15285/Volunteering-with-community-greenspace
47. Perthshire Seed Library - Culture Perth & Kinross, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.culturepk.org.uk/libraries/services-and-programs/perthshire-seed-library/
48. Food Growing Strategy 2021 - Perth & Kinross Council, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/media/48957/Food-Growing-Strategy-August-2021-Adopted/pdf/Food_Growing_Strategy_Aug21_Adopted_Website.pdf?m=637728339891830000
49. Allotments and growing spaces - Existing growing spaces - Perth & Kinross Council, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/15331/Allotments-and-growing-spaces-Existing-growing-spaces
50. Strategy - Invest in Perth, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.investinperth.co.uk/strategy
51. Land Use - Perth and Kinross Climate Action, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.pkclimateaction.co.uk/land-use
52. Broch Field Asset Transfer Request - Forestry and Land Scotland, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://forestryandland.gov.scot/media/a24jljga/a1_-_broch_field_asset_transfer_request.pdf
53. Asset transfer | Scottish Borders Council, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.scotborders.gov.uk/strategies-plans-policies/asset-transfer
54. New community woodland, recreation & food growing area set for Inverness after Community Asset Transfer agreed | The Highland Council, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.highland.gov.uk/news/article/16069/new_community_woodland_recreation_and_food_growing_area_set_for_inverness_after_community_asset_transfer_agreed
55. Community orchards – tragedy or victory of the commons?, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.theorchardproject.org.uk/blog/community-orchards-tragedy-or-victory-of-the-commons/
56. How Do Green Spaces Promote Community Cohesion? - Lifestyle → Sustainability Directory, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://lifestyle.sustainability-directory.com/question/how-do-green-spaces-promote-community-cohesion/
57. The Dynamic Relationship between Social Cohesion and Urban Green Space in Diverse Communities: Opportunities and Challenges to Public Health - MDPI, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/21/6/800
58. Growing Orchard Communities in South Devon - National Landscapes, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://national-landscapes.org.uk/news/growing-orchard-communities-in-south-devon
59. Social Cohesion and City Green Space: Revisiting the Power of Volunteering - MDPI, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.mdpi.com/2078-1547/10/2/36
60. Designing for resiliency: social study on the effects of community gardens. - UPCommons, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://upcommons.upc.edu/bitstream/handle/2117/395094/Rola_Dalloul_Master_Thesis_A4_landscape.pdf?sequence=2
61. Tips to Engage Community in your Orchard - The Giving Grove, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.givinggrove.org/workshop-blog/tips-to-engage-community-in-your-orchard
62. 5 Steps to Building Community for Your Community Orchard or Garden - YouTube, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-n2k4_Usl0U
63. We'd like to use additional cookies to understand how you use the site and improve our services. - UK Parliament Committees, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/125891/html/
64. Written evidence submitted by The Orchard Project (UGS0070) - UK Parliament Committees, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/125891/pdf/
65. Types of Community Group (Scotland) - The Wildlife Trusts, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.wildlifetrusts.org/sites/default/files/2022-10/TypesOfGroup_GAI.pdf
66. Legal Structures - Community Transport Association, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://ctauk.org/sites/default/files/2024-08/Legal%20Structures.pdf
67. 1.1 Legal Structures | Resource Library, accessed on August 8, 2025, http://www.vaslan.org.uk/resourcekit/10-getting-started/11-legal-structures
68. Planning and designing an orchard, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.theorchardproject.org.uk/guides_and_advice/things-to-look-out-for-when-planning-an-orchard/
69. Community Orchard - Scotmid Co-operative, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://scotmid.coop/community-orchard/
70. Development plan - Perth & Kinross Council, accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/15040/Development-plan
71. Perth City Centre Development & Design Framework., accessed on August 8, 2025, https://www.investinperth.co.uk/files/Documents/UG2247_Perth-City-Centre_Development-and-Design-Framework_2024.10.24_V7-2_compressed-1.pdf