Weaving the Tartan Tighter: A Strategic Framework for Social Cohesion in Perth and Kinross

Executive Summary

Social cohesion—the intricate web of trust, belonging, and shared purpose that binds a community—is a critical, measurable, and strategic asset for the future prosperity, health, and resilience of Perth and Kinross. This report, prepared for the think tank Civic Prism, moves beyond abstract definitions to present an evidence-based, actionable framework for strengthening the social fabric of the region. It argues that a deliberate and sustained investment in social cohesion is not a discretionary expense but a foundational requirement for navigating the complex challenges of the 21st century.

The analysis identifies a unique set of challenges confronting Perth and Kinross. Beneath a veneer of affluence lies a more complex story of hidden poverty, often dispersed across its vast rural geography and therefore missed by conventional deprivation metrics. This "friction of distance" exacerbates social isolation, creating barriers to service access and community participation. Compounding this is a demographic shift towards an older population, increasing the risk of loneliness, and a growing, increasingly diverse migrant community, particularly linked to seasonal agricultural work, whose integration is vital for both economic success and community harmony.

Drawing on extensive international research and successful policy models from Canada, New Zealand, Australia, and Germany, this report demonstrates that these challenges can be transformed into opportunities. The most effective strategies are those that move beyond simple service delivery and actively engage the host community in the process of welcoming and integration, thereby strengthening the bonds of the entire society.

The report culminates in a strategic framework tailored to the specific context of Perth and Kinross, built upon four interconnected goals:

1. Deepen Community Empowerment and Participation: Evolving existing local partnerships into formal Local Cohesion Partnerships, modeled on Canada's successful Local Immigration Partnerships (LIPs), to drive hyper-local planning and action.
2. Drive Economic Inclusion and Reduce Inequality: Formally integrating social cohesion outcomes into the region's anti-poverty strategy, recognizing that economic fairness is the bedrock of social trust.
3. Launch a "Welcoming Perth and Kinross" Initiative: Adapting New Zealand's acclaimed "Welcoming Communities" framework to create a coordinated, proactive strategy for integrating newcomers, particularly seasonal workers, and making the entire region more inclusive.
4. Create Shared Spaces and Foster Intercultural Dialogue: Piloting a "Rural Community Hubs" program based on the proven Australian model, using existing assets like village halls and schools to co-locate services and create vital points of connection. This is complemented by establishing an annual Multicultural Festival to celebrate the region's diversity and build shared identity.

By implementing this framework, Perth and Kinross can weave its diverse threads—urban and rural, long-standing residents and new arrivals, young and old—into a tighter, more resilient, and more prosperous whole. This report provides the blueprint for that essential work.

Section 1: The Foundations of a Cohesive Society

To construct effective policy, it is imperative to move beyond intuitive descriptions of social cohesion and establish a robust, operational definition. While often conceived of as the "glue" that holds a social system together, a deeper analysis reveals a multi-dimensional concept rooted in academic theory and refined by international policy bodies into a practical framework for intervention and measurement.¹

1.1 Defining Social Cohesion: From Abstract to Actionable

The term social cohesion has become a cornerstone of socio-political discourse, intuitively understood as the bonds that allow a society to 'hang together'.¹ At its most fundamental level, it describes the "nature and quality of the emotional bonds of friendship, liking, caring, and closeness among group members".⁴ This micro-level psychological foundation scales up to a societal characteristic, reflecting a collective preference for cooperation and mutual support.²

The intellectual heritage of the concept can be traced to classical sociologists such as Émile Durkheim and Ferdinand Tönnies, who analyzed the transition from traditional to modern societies.¹ Durkheim's distinction between "mechanical solidarity" (based on common values and beliefs in homogenous communities) and "organic solidarity" (based on interdependence and cooperation in diverse, complex societies) is particularly salient. Modern social cohesion aligns with the principles of organic solidarity, emphasizing the need for shared purpose and collaboration amidst diversity, rather than a return to an imagined homogenous past.¹

Contemporary scholarship has synthesized these ideas into a set of core components. These consistently include:

• Trust: Both interpersonal trust between citizens and vertical trust between citizens and public institutions.²
• Sense of Belonging: A shared identity and feeling of being part of a common enterprise, facing shared challenges.²
• Participation: Active engagement in civic, social, and political life.¹
• Equality and Inclusion: The reduction of inequalities, exclusions, and disparities, ensuring all members of society have access to opportunities.¹
• Solidarity and Orientation towards the Common Good: A willingness to cooperate and contribute to collective wellbeing, extending beyond one's immediate group.²

These components are not merely abstract values; they are observable and can be influenced by policy. A society is cohesive to the extent that it actively reduces marginalization and enables its members to work together towards shared goals.¹

1.2 A Multi-Dimensional Framework for Policy

The various academic definitions of social cohesion are not contradictory but complementary, describing the phenomenon across different levels of analysis (individual, community, societal) and along different dimensions (horizontal relationships between people versus vertical relationships with institutions). To translate this complex concept into a practical tool for policy, it is useful to adopt and synthesize the multi-dimensional frameworks developed by leading international organizations. This integrated approach provides a powerful diagnostic for identifying specific strengths and weaknesses within a community's social fabric.

The OECD Model: Three Pillars of a Cohesive Society

The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) defines a cohesive society as one that "works towards the well-being of all its members, fights exclusion and marginalisation, creates a sense of belonging, promotes trust, and offers its members the opportunity of upward social mobility".⁹ It measures this through three core, equally important dimensions:

1. Social Inclusion: This dimension focuses on the extent of exclusion and marginalization within a society. It is measured through objective indicators such as poverty rates, income inequality, and social polarization, examining whether all citizens have access to fundamental social and economic rights and the means to secure their basic needs.⁸
2. Social Capital: This refers to the "networks of relationships between individuals and groups, the degree of interpersonal and societal trust and the level of civic participation".⁹ It is the practical manifestation of trust and reciprocity, often seen as the tool through which social cohesion is achieved.⁸
3. Social Mobility: This is the degree to which individuals are able, or believe they are able, to improve their position in society.⁹ It reflects the promise of equal opportunity and is a critical component for maintaining fairness and a sense of shared purpose.

A key strength of the OECD framework is its insistence on combining objective data (e.g., poverty lines) with subjective, perception-based aspects (e.g., life satisfaction, sense of belonging) for a holistic understanding.⁹

The World Bank Model: The Relational Dynamics of Cohesion

The World Bank complements this thematic approach by focusing on the relational dynamics of social cohesion. It defines cohesion as a "sense of shared purpose, trust and willingness to cooperate" that exists across three distinct sets of relationships.¹⁰

1. Bonding Capital: The ties that connect individuals within a homogenous community or group (e.g., among close family, neighbours of the same ethnic background).¹²
2. Bridging Capital: The ties that connect individuals across distinct communities or social divides (e.g., between different ethnic groups, age groups, or socio-economic classes).¹²
3. Linking Capital: The vertical ties that connect citizens to people or structures in positions of power, such as local government and public institutions. This dimension is critical for institutional legitimacy and empowering people to hold the state accountable.¹²

The first two (bonding and bridging) constitute horizontal cohesion, while the third (linking) represents vertical cohesion.¹² This framework is particularly useful for diagnosing the nature of social fractures. A community might have strong bonding capital but weak bridging capital, leading to insular and potentially hostile inter-group relations. Conversely, weak linking capital can signify a profound disconnect between citizens and their government, eroding trust and legitimacy.

By synthesizing these two models, a powerful analytical matrix emerges for Perth and Kinross. Policy can be structured around the OECD's thematic pillars (Inclusion, Capital, Mobility) and then analyzed through the lens of the World Bank's relational dynamics (Bonding, Bridging, Linking). This allows for the development of highly specific interventions. For instance, a policy could aim to improve Social Inclusion by designing a program that specifically strengthens Bridging Capital between migrant agricultural workers and the longer-standing rural communities in which they reside. This composite framework transforms social cohesion from a laudable but vague goal into a clear and measurable policy objective.

Section 2: The Dividends of Cohesion: A Multi-faceted Analysis

Investing in social cohesion yields tangible, evidence-based returns that cascade across economic, public health, and community resilience domains. A cohesive society is not merely a more pleasant place to live; it is more prosperous, healthier, and better equipped to handle adversity. The benefits are not siloed but create reinforcing positive feedback loops, making social cohesion a highly efficient and impactful area for public investment.

2.1 Economic Prosperity and Stability

There is a consistent and positive relationship between social cohesion and economic growth.¹⁴ Cohesive societies tend to have better economic outcomes because the foundational elements of trust, cooperation, and shared norms directly facilitate economic activity.

Firstly, social cohesion reduces transaction costs. In high-trust environments, economic exchanges require less formal enforcement, information flows more freely, and contractual practices are more reliable.¹⁷ This stability and predictability makes communities more attractive to investors, who perceive them as being less prone to conflict and therefore lower-risk.¹⁸

Secondly, cohesion fosters entrepreneurship and innovation. The culture of mutual support and cooperation inherent in cohesive communities encourages the development of new businesses and the creation of jobs.¹⁸ Furthermore, diversity, when managed within a cohesive framework, can lead to increased creativity as different perspectives and experiences interact to generate new ideas.¹⁹

Thirdly, cohesive communities are more effective at providing and maintaining public goods, such as transportation systems, schools, and healthcare facilities.¹⁷ A shared sense of purpose and a willingness to contribute to the common good overcomes collective action problems, leading to better infrastructure and services that support economic stability.¹⁸ Reduced social polarization also limits rent-seeking behaviour and fosters a political climate more conducive to investing in public goods, which ultimately benefits growth.¹⁴

This relationship is cyclical. While cohesion drives growth, inclusive economic growth can, in turn, reinforce cohesion. When economic development creates employment, reduces inequality, and generates tax revenues for social protection and education, it strengthens the bonds holding society together.¹⁴ This creates the potential for a virtuous cycle where economic prosperity and social stability mutually reinforce one another.

2.2 Public Health and Collective Wellbeing

Social cohesion is a powerful social determinant of health, with a profound impact on both mental and physical wellbeing.²¹ The quality of social connections within a community can be a more significant predictor of health outcomes than material factors alone.

Research demonstrates that social cohesion in neighbourhoods has a greater impact on mental health than the level of economic deprivation.²³ Cohesive neighbourhoods provide a tangible buffer against the negative effects of poverty through increased social support, interaction, and the exchange of favours.²³ A sense of trust, a feeling of belonging to the local community, and feeling valued are among the strongest predictors of individual wellbeing.²³ People who feel connected to their neighbours and trust others are significantly more likely to report being in "good health".²³

The physical environment plays a crucial role in facilitating these health-promoting connections. Public spaces like parks, libraries, and community centres act as "meeting places" that are vital for building social ties, fostering reciprocal trust, and encouraging civic participation.²³ Community-led activities, such as formal volunteering, not only improve the quality of these shared spaces but also build the resilience of both the individuals who participate and the community as a whole.²³

Conversely, threats to cohesion, such as anti-social behaviour, crime, and "incivilities," are particularly damaging to wellbeing and can create a sense of social disorder and disharmony that erodes the positive effects of community connection.²³

2.3 Community Resilience and Adaptability

A strong social fabric is the foundation of community resilience, defined as the ability to withstand, adapt to, and recover from shocks and stresses.²⁴ These can range from acute shocks like natural disasters, economic crises, or public health emergencies, to chronic stresses such as poverty, inequality, or demographic change.¹²

The World Bank identifies social cohesion as a critical asset, particularly in fragile and conflict-afflicted settings. It is essential for preventing violent conflict and for helping societies transition out of fragility because it fosters the trust and willingness to cooperate that are necessary for peacebuilding, reconciliation, and the establishment of legitimate, responsive governance.¹⁰ The UN-World Bank study

Pathways for Peace argues that fostering inclusiveness and social cohesion is "the essence of prevention".¹²

Beyond conflict settings, cohesive communities are better able to manage shared resources and respond collectively to other major challenges. For instance, strong social networks proved vital during the COVID-19 pandemic for disseminating information, providing mutual aid, and supporting vulnerable individuals.¹² Similarly, as communities face the escalating impacts of climate change, the ability to act collectively to adapt and implement mitigation strategies will be paramount.¹² Socially cohesive communities are more likely to possess the trust and civic engagement needed to identify shared problems and implement solutions together, making them more adaptable and resilient in the face of uncertainty.¹²

The interconnectedness of these benefits reveals a powerful dynamic for policymakers. An investment in one area can trigger a positive feedback loop across others. For example, a community-led project to create a shared public garden (a resilience and public space initiative) directly builds social networks and trust (social capital).⁸ These enhanced networks can reduce social isolation, thereby improving mental health outcomes.²³ This strengthened social capital can then foster local economic activity, such as a community market for the garden's produce.¹⁸ This demonstrates that well-designed social cohesion policies offer a high return on investment precisely because their impacts are multiplicative across health, economic, and social systems.

Section 3: Immigration as an Engine for Cohesion: Fostering Integration in a Diverse Society

A common narrative frames immigration as a stress test for social cohesion, a force that strains resources and challenges established identities. This report posits an alternative view: that immigration, when managed through a strategic and inclusive integration process, can be a powerful engine for strengthening a community's social fabric. The process of successfully integrating newcomers forces a society to practice and reinforce its most essential cohesive values, while the contributions of migrant communities add dynamism, diversity, and resilience.

3.1 The Positive Contributions of Migrant Communities

Migrant communities are a significant source of economic, cultural, and demographic vitality. Their contributions are essential for the long-term prosperity of regions like Perth and Kinross.

• Economic Dynamism: Immigrants bring diverse skills, fill critical labour market gaps, and exhibit high rates of entrepreneurship, stimulating economic growth and innovation.¹⁹ In sectors vital to Perth and Kinross, such as agriculture, hospitality, and social care, migrant workers are often indispensable.²⁷ Their economic activity contributes tax revenue that funds public services, and their presence can revitalize local economies by creating new businesses and jobs.¹⁸
• Cultural Enrichment: Migration enriches the cultural landscape of a community, introducing new customs, traditions, cuisines, and perspectives.¹⁹ This cultural exchange fosters creativity, broadens horizons, and promotes intercultural understanding.¹⁹ Immigrants and their children have historically played a disproportionate role in artistic and scientific innovation, often because their marginality fosters a curiosity and openness to new ideas that can challenge and invigorate established conventions.²⁹
• Demographic Rejuvenation: In regions with aging populations and low birth rates, such as Perth and Kinross, immigration is a crucial source of demographic renewal.¹⁹ Newcomers help to balance the age structure, sustain the workforce, and bring new energy and vitality to communities, ensuring the long-term viability of public services and local economies.¹⁹

3.2 Integration as a Cohesion-Building Process

The key to unlocking the benefits of migration lies in the process of integration. Effective integration should not be viewed as a one-way process of assimilation, where newcomers are expected to shed their identities. Rather, it is a dynamic, two-way process of mutual adaptation between immigrants and the host society.³¹ When a community commits to this process, it strengthens its own social cohesion in several fundamental ways.

First, the very act of developing and implementing inclusive policies—such as accessible language training, robust anti-discrimination measures, and programs that facilitate cultural exchange—builds the entire community's capacity for dialogue, empathy, and cooperation.¹⁹ It forces institutions to become more responsive and accessible to all residents, not just newcomers.

Second, the success of immigrant integration serves as a powerful public barometer of a society's overall social health. Challenges encountered by newcomers often illuminate pre-existing fractures within the host community. For instance, if tensions arise over competition for housing or jobs, it is frequently a symptom of a broader, pre-existing shortage of affordable housing or a lack of quality employment opportunities that affects the entire population.³³ Similarly, if newcomers experience discrimination in accessing services, it may reveal systemic inequities that also impact other marginalized groups within the host community.

By focusing policy attention on the barriers faced by the most recent arrivals, decision-makers are often compelled to address these deeper, systemic problems. Fixing a convoluted process for recognizing foreign credentials can lead to broader reforms that benefit all workers. Building more affordable housing to accommodate newcomers helps alleviate pressure on the entire housing market. In this sense, addressing the challenges of integration is not a zero-sum game; it is a process that can lift the entire community by forcing a confrontation with and resolution of its underlying weaknesses. When a community successfully integrates newcomers, it is not just helping them; it is proving to itself that its values of fairness, opportunity, and mutual respect are robust and functional, thereby reinforcing the very foundations of its own social cohesion.

Section 4: International Models of Integration and Cohesion: Lessons for Perth and Kinross

To develop an effective local strategy, it is essential to learn from established international best practices. Countries with long histories of immigration have developed sophisticated, multi-layered approaches to fostering social cohesion and integrating newcomers. While no single model can be imported wholesale, a comparative analysis of their core principles and mechanisms provides a rich evidence base of transferable ideas. The most successful models share a crucial characteristic: they move beyond a simple "service delivery" mindset and actively engage the host community in the process of welcoming, thereby building the vital "bridging" social capital that connects diverse groups.

Table 2: Comparative Analysis of International Integration Models

4.1 Canada: Multi-Level Governance and Community Sponsorship

Canada's approach is distinguished by its formal, top-down commitment to multiculturalism combined with highly localized, bottom-up implementation. The Canadian Multiculturalism Act provides a robust legal and philosophical foundation, officially recognizing cultural diversity as a fundamental characteristic of Canadian identity and society.³⁰

This national framework enables innovative local action. The Local Immigration Partnerships (LIPs) are a prime example. LIPs are community-based councils that bring together a wide range of local stakeholders—including employers, school boards, healthcare providers, libraries, and social service agencies—to develop and implement a shared strategic plan for welcoming and integrating newcomers.³⁵ This model ensures that integration efforts are tailored to local realities and fosters a sense of collective ownership and responsibility.

Furthermore, Canada's Private Sponsorship of Refugees Program is a globally recognized model for engaging civil society directly in resettlement.³⁶ It allows community groups, faith-based organizations, and even groups of five or more citizens to take on the financial and social responsibility of supporting a refugee family for their first year in Canada.³⁷ This program has proven highly effective not only in providing a durable solution for hundreds of thousands of refugees but also in building social cohesion within the host community itself. By bringing diverse residents together for a common, humanitarian purpose, it "reanimates life at the community level" and builds powerful bonds of trust and reciprocity.³⁶

4.2 New Zealand: A National Framework for Local Welcoming

New Zealand's "Welcoming Communities" (Te Waharoa ki ngā Hapori) programme offers a compelling model of national-local partnership.⁴⁰ Led by Immigration New Zealand, the programme provides funding and support to local councils to help them become more welcoming and inclusive. It is not a prescriptive, one-size-fits-all approach. Instead, it empowers local communities to design their own initiatives based on local needs.⁴⁰

The heart of the programme is the Welcoming Standard, an outcomes-based framework co-designed with participating communities.⁴³ The Standard outlines eight key elements of a welcoming community, including "Inclusive Leadership," "Connected and Inclusive Communities," and "Welcoming Public Spaces".⁴⁴ This provides a clear benchmark for councils to assess their progress and develop a tailored "Welcome Plan" to address identified gaps.⁴⁴ Evaluations of the programme have demonstrated its success in strengthening local networks, increasing newcomer confidence in engaging with councils, and fostering a more visible leadership role for local government in promoting diversity.⁴¹

4.3 Australia: Place-Based Hubs and Cultural Celebration

Australia's integration strategy offers two particularly relevant and effective models. The first is the Community Hubs model, a place-based initiative that has proven remarkably successful in connecting migrant families with essential services and with each other.⁴⁵ These hubs are typically located within primary schools, leveraging existing, trusted community infrastructure. They act as a "soft entry point," offering a range of co-located services such as English language classes, supported playgroups for children, health clinics, and skills training.⁴⁵ This approach removes barriers to access and creates a welcoming environment where parents can build social networks while their children prepare for school. Crucially, the model has demonstrated a strong social return on investment, with evaluations showing it improves children's educational outcomes, increases parental employment, and significantly enhances participants' quality of life and sense of connection.⁴⁵

Secondly, Australia effectively utilizes multicultural festivals and events as a strategic tool for fostering social cohesion.⁴⁶ Supported by government grant programs, these events provide an open and inclusive platform for different cultural groups to share and celebrate their traditions with the broader community.⁴⁶ Evidence shows that such events reduce social isolation, encourage cooperation, build community networks, and improve psychological wellbeing for participants.⁴⁶ They are a practical and highly visible way to build mutual understanding and a shared sense of pride in a community's diversity.⁴⁸

4.4 Sweden & Germany: Structured Integration Programmes

The approaches in Sweden and Germany highlight the value of structured, state-led integration pathways, particularly for language acquisition and labour market entry. Sweden's "Establishment Programme" is a mandatory, two-year, full-time programme for newly arrived refugees.⁵⁰ Run by the national Public Employment Service in close cooperation with municipalities, it provides an intensive and integrated package of support, including Swedish for Immigrants (SFI) courses, civic orientation, and job coaching.⁵¹ While facing challenges, this model underscores the importance of a comprehensive, resourced, and coordinated system for initial settlement.⁵²

Similarly, Germany's nationwide "Integration Courses" are a cornerstone of its national strategy.⁵⁴ These courses, which combine language and orientation modules, are offered to all newcomers and provide a standardized foundation in the German language and knowledge of the country's legal system, history, and culture.⁵⁵ Local governments play a critical role in refugee integration, with cities like Berlin developing innovative "welcome classes" in schools to quickly integrate refugee children into the education system.⁵⁷ These models demonstrate the efficacy of a clear, structured framework for providing newcomers with the foundational skills needed for successful integration.

Section 5: The Perth and Kinross Context: Challenges and Opportunities

A successful social cohesion strategy cannot be generic; it must be deeply rooted in the specific demographic, economic, and social realities of the place it serves. Perth and Kinross presents a unique and complex picture: a region of significant geographic scale, outward prosperity that masks hidden hardship, and a demographic profile that is simultaneously aging and becoming more culturally diverse. Understanding these specific local characteristics is essential for adapting international best practices into a framework that is fit for purpose.

Table 1: Demographic and Social Profile of Perth and Kinross vs. Scotland

5.1 A Tale of Two Regions: Affluence and Hidden Deprivation

Perth and Kinross is often perceived as a prosperous area, an image supported by headline data showing high employment rates and average earnings.⁶⁰ However, this aggregate picture conceals a more complex and challenging reality. A closer examination reveals a "story of place, with hidden crises such as low wages and social isolation, affecting many".⁶³ The difference between the most affluent communities and those living in adversity is stark.⁶³

A significant challenge is that poverty in Perth and Kinross is often dispersed across its rural landscape, rather than being concentrated in urban data zones.⁶⁵ This makes it difficult to identify and target using standard metrics like the Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD), which can lead to an underestimation of need and an inequitable distribution of resources.⁶⁵ This rural poverty is compounded by a higher cost of living, particularly for transport and fuel, meaning that income-based poverty measures may not capture the full extent of hardship.⁶³

Child poverty is a particularly acute issue, with reports indicating that nearly 6,000 children in the region are living in poverty.⁶⁴ The primary drivers of this are consistent with national trends: insufficient income from employment, with just under one in three local workers in lower-paid occupations; the high cost of living, especially for housing and energy; and the negative impacts of welfare reforms.⁶³ These economic pressures create daily struggles for thousands of families, restricting life chances and undermining the foundations of social cohesion.⁶⁴

5.2 Demographic Landscape: An Aging, Rural, and Increasingly Diverse Community

The demographic profile of Perth and Kinross presents a distinct set of challenges and opportunities. The region is the eighth least densely populated council area in Scotland, characterized by a wide geographical spread and a mix of urban centres and remote rural communities.⁶¹ This geography creates what can be termed a "friction of distance," which complicates the delivery of public services and can exacerbate social isolation for vulnerable residents.⁶³ Access to transport, digital connectivity, and centralized services are persistent challenges, particularly for those in outlying areas.⁶³

The population is also significantly older than the Scottish average, with almost a quarter of residents aged 65 and over, a proportion that has increased notably since 2011.⁶¹ While this reflects the region's appeal as a place to live, it also increases demand on health and social care services and heightens the risk of loneliness and isolation among older residents, a key threat to social cohesion.

Simultaneously, the community is becoming more culturally diverse. While the population remains predominantly White, there has been a significant increase in migration, particularly from EU countries.²⁷ The 2022 Census recorded over 3,400 residents of Polish background and over 5,000 categorized as 'Other White,' which includes many from other Eastern European nations.²⁷ A 2019 report highlighted that adult labour migration was hugely dominated by citizens from Romania, Bulgaria, and Poland, with this migration often being seasonal and linked to key local industries like agriculture, food processing, and hospitality.⁶⁸ This pattern of seasonal and rural-based migration presents a unique integration challenge, as workers may be geographically and socially isolated from mainstream services and community life.

5.3 Existing Assets and Strategic Commitments

Despite these challenges, Perth and Kinross possesses significant assets and a strong strategic foundation upon which to build a more cohesive society.

• The Perth and Kinross Offer: This is the Council's core strategic vision, explicitly committing to working in partnership with communities, empowering them to make decisions, and creating a "better, greener and fairer place to live, learn, work, play and visit".⁶⁹ Its focus on putting people at the heart of service design and directing resources where they are most needed provides an ideal policy framework for launching a dedicated social cohesion agenda.⁶⁹
• A Framework for Community Empowerment: The Council has already established a suite of mechanisms designed to give communities greater influence and control. These include Local Action Partnerships, the right to Community Asset Transfer, and processes for Locality Participatory Budgeting.⁷⁰ These existing structures are invaluable assets that can be leveraged and adapted to drive community-led cohesion-building projects.
• A Vibrant and Collaborative Third Sector: The region benefits from a robust and highly active third sector. The Third Sector Interface (TSI) Perth & Kinross, a service provided by the charity PKAVS, plays a vital coordinating role. It supports hundreds of local charities and community groups, enables collaboration, and represents the sector's voice at a strategic level.⁷¹ PKAVS itself delivers a wide range of direct services to vulnerable groups, including unpaid carers, individuals with mental health challenges, and minority communities.⁷³ Organizations like
  Independent Advocacy Perth and Kinross provide targeted support for asylum seekers and refugees, helping them navigate services and build community connections.⁷⁵ This established network of experienced and trusted community organizations is the most critical asset for delivering on-the-ground social cohesion initiatives.

Section 6: A Strategic Framework for Enhancing Social Cohesion in Perth and Kinross

Building on the international evidence and the specific local context, this section proposes a comprehensive and actionable strategic framework for Perth and Kinross. The framework is organized around four interconnected strategic goals, each supported by specific, evidence-based recommendations. These recommendations are designed to be integrated into existing structures, leveraging the region's assets to address its unique challenges. The overarching aim is to move from a series of disparate initiatives to a coordinated, strategic, and long-term investment in the social fabric of the community.

Table 3: Strategic Recommendations Framework

6.1 Strategic Goal 1: Deepen Community Empowerment and Participation

The foundation of a cohesive community is the ability of its residents to participate in and shape its future. Perth and Kinross has strong existing structures for community empowerment that can be enhanced and focused.⁷⁰

Recommendation: Evolve the existing Local Action Partnerships into formal Local Cohesion Partnerships, drawing inspiration from the successful Canadian Local Immigration Partnerships (LIPs) model.³⁵ While the current partnerships provide a forum for community involvement, formalizing their remit to include social cohesion and integration would give them a clearer strategic purpose. These partnerships, representing diverse local stakeholders, should be mandated to develop and monitor hyper-local cohesion and integration plans. To facilitate this, dedicated funding, managed through the Third Sector Interface (TSI), should be provided to hire a part-time coordinator for each partnership, ensuring consistent progress and coordination.⁷¹ Furthermore, a portion of the Council's Community Investment Fund and Locality Participatory Budgeting funds should be ring-fenced for projects explicitly designed to strengthen local social bonds, allowing residents to directly invest in the cohesion of their own neighbourhoods.⁷⁰

6.2 Strategic Goal 2: Drive Economic Inclusion and Reduce Inequality

Social cohesion cannot be built on a foundation of profound economic inequality. The persistent challenge of child poverty and in-work poverty in Perth and Kinross is a direct threat to the social fabric.⁶⁴

Recommendation: Formally integrate social cohesion outcomes into the Local Child Poverty Action Report (LCPAR) and the strategic work of the region's Anti-Poverty Task Force.⁶⁴ This requires a conceptual shift: framing actions to boost incomes, reduce living costs, and maximize benefit uptake not merely as anti-poverty measures, but as fundamental investments in building a more cohesive society.⁶³ The annual LCPAR should include indicators that measure social cohesion metrics, such as feelings of isolation, community trust, and belonging, among low-income families to track progress. Public communications should explicitly link the drive for a Living Wage and fair work with the goal of creating a fairer, more connected community. Employability support, such as the Council's Skills Academies, should be proactively targeted at priority groups identified in the LCPAR, with a particular focus on migrant women who may face additional barriers to employment.⁶³

6.3 Strategic Goal 3: Launch a "Welcoming Perth and Kinross" Initiative

To harness the positive potential of migration and address the specific integration challenges of a dispersed, often seasonal, migrant population, a coordinated and visible welcoming strategy is required.

Recommendation: Adopt and adapt New Zealand's highly successful "Welcoming Communities" framework to create a flagship "Welcoming Perth and Kinross" initiative.⁴⁰ This would involve appointing a dedicated "Welcoming Communities Coordinator" within the Council to lead the development of a local "Welcome Plan" in partnership with key stakeholders, including community groups like PKAVS, employers in the agricultural and hospitality sectors, and representatives from migrant communities themselves.⁷⁷ Key actions under this plan would include the creation of multilingual "Welcome Packs" with essential information on local services, housing, and employment rights, and the establishment of a "Language Friend" mentoring program, adapting a model used effectively in cities like Gothenburg, to pair newcomers with local volunteers for informal language practice and social connection.⁵³

6.4 Strategic Goal 4: Create Shared Spaces and Foster Intercultural Dialogue

Overcoming the "friction of distance" inherent in Perth and Kinross's geography requires a deliberate strategy to create physical and cultural spaces for connection.

Recommendation: Pilot a "Rural Community Hubs" program, adapting the evidence-based Australian model to the local context.⁴⁵ Instead of building new infrastructure, this initiative would leverage existing community assets—village halls, libraries, and rural primary schools—as hubs for co-locating services and community activities. These hubs would be ideal venues for informal English conversation circles, parent-and-toddler groups open to all families, digital literacy workshops for older residents, and drop-in sessions for vital services like welfare rights advice. This place-based approach directly tackles the challenge of rural service delivery and creates natural opportunities for interaction between different groups, reducing isolation and building bridging social capital.

Recommendation: Establish an annual Perth and Kinross Multicultural Festival and a supporting grants program for smaller, localized cultural events, drawing on the Australian experience of using such events to build community pride and positive inter-group contact.⁴⁶ The flagship festival would be a highly visible celebration of the diverse cultures that contribute to the region, including the large Polish, Romanian, and other Eastern European communities.⁶⁸ The associated grants fund would empower small community groups across the region to organize their own events, fostering a year-round culture of celebration and intercultural dialogue that strengthens shared identity and belonging.

Conclusion

Social cohesion is not a passive outcome of favourable circumstances, but an active and continuous process of community-building that requires strategic vision, sustained investment, and collective effort. For Perth and Kinross, a region defined by its unique blend of rural geography, demographic change, and the paradox of visible affluence alongside hidden inequality, strengthening the social fabric is the most critical task for securing its future. The challenges of social isolation, dispersed poverty, and the integration of new communities are significant, but they are not insurmountable.

This report has demonstrated that a wealth of international evidence provides a clear pathway forward. The most resilient, healthy, and prosperous societies are those that intentionally cultivate inclusion, trust, and participation. They build bridges between diverse groups, empower local communities to solve their own problems, and ensure that the benefits of economic growth are shared equitably. They understand that welcoming newcomers is not a burden but an opportunity to enrich and strengthen the entire community.

The strategic framework presented here offers a pragmatic, evidence-based roadmap for Perth and Kinross to do just that. By adapting proven models like Canada's Local Immigration Partnerships, New Zealand's "Welcoming Communities" programme, and Australia's Community Hubs, the region can leverage its existing assets—a committed Council, a vibrant third sector, and strong community spirit—to address its specific challenges. This is not about importing foreign solutions, but about learning from global best practices to craft a response that is authentically tailored to Perth and Kinross.

The journey towards a more cohesive society is a long-term commitment. It requires leadership from public bodies, engagement from businesses and civil society, and the active participation of all residents. The recommendations in this report—from formalizing local cohesion partnerships to launching a rural hubs pilot—are the essential first steps on that journey. By taking them, Perth and Kinross can turn its challenges into opportunities for connection, building a future where everyone, in every part of the region, can truly live life well and feel a positive sense of belonging. This is the most profound and valuable investment the region can make in its long-term resilience and prosperity.

Works cited

1. Chapter 4: Social Cohesion. Critical Theoretical Exploration of a ..., accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.vr-elibrary.de/doi/full/10.13109/9783666568558.65
2. (PDF) Defining Social Cohesion - ResearchGate, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/381407364_Defining_Social_Cohesion
3. Social Cohesion: Concept and Measurement - UNECE, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://unece.org/sites/default/files/2023-12/2317603_E_ECE_CES_STAT_2023_8_WEB.pdf
4. psychiatry.ucsd.edu, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://psychiatry.ucsd.edu/research/programs-centers/instep/tools-resource/definitions/emergent-states/affective-emergent-states/social-cohesion.html#:~:text=Definition,157))
5. Social Cohesion - UCSD Psychiatry, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://psychiatry.ucsd.edu/research/programs-centers/instep/tools-resource/definitions/emergent-states/affective-emergent-states/social-cohesion.html
6. Concepts - Social Cohesion, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.socialcohesion.info/concepts
7. Social cohesion revisited: a new definition and how to characterize it, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13511610.2018.1497480
8. The Concept of Social Cohesion: Overview and Historical Perspective 1 - Commonwealth iLibrary, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.thecommonwealth-ilibrary.org/index.php/comsec/catalog/download/322/319/2729?inline=1
9. OECD Definition of Social Cohesion, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.socialcohesion.info/concepts/concept/oecd
10. Social Cohesion and Resilience - World Bank, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/social-cohesion-and-resilience
11. Technical Training Social Cohesion in Forced Displacement Contexts: Challenges, Evidence and Programming - World Bank, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.worldbank.org/content/dam/videos/fcv/2023/nov/202311018-Module7-SocialCohesion.pdf
12. Leveraging Social Cohesion for Development Outcomes - Open ..., accessed on July 26, 2025, https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstreams/46fe1edf-f941-4022-8ae1-9d57622b61d3/download
13. Leveraging Social Cohesion for Development Outcomes (English), accessed on July 26, 2025, https://documents.worldbank.org/en/publication/documents-reports/documentdetail/099723304202334301/idu0053a35270965b0414f090ff0157bb9183a68
14. Social Cohesion and Economic Development: Unpacking the ..., accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.idos-research.de/uploads/media/BP_16.2019.pdf
15. Social cohesion and economic development: Unpacking the relationship - EconStor, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/206857/1/bp-16-2019.pdf
16. Social cohesion and economic development: unpacking the relationship, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.idos-research.de/en/briefing-paper/article/social-cohesion-and-economic-development-unpacking-the-relationship/
17. Social Cohesion for Economic Growth - AWS, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://tepav.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/upload/files/1458830335-3.Social_Cohesion_for_Economic_Growth.pdf
18. Building Social Cohesion in Economic Development, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.numberanalytics.com/blog/building-social-cohesion-in-economic-development
19. Migration and Social Cohesion: A Complex Relationship - Number Analytics, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.numberanalytics.com/blog/migration-and-social-cohesion
20. Publications – Planning in Australia: economic benefits of cultural diversity, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://sgsep.com.au/publications/insights/economic-benefits-of-cultural-diversity
21. Social and Community Context | Prepare Your Health - CDC, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.cdc.gov/prepyourhealth/discussionguides/community.htm
22. Social Determinants of Health - Healthy People 2030 | odphp.health.gov, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://odphp.health.gov/healthypeople/priority-areas/social-determinants-health
23. Understanding the Effects of Social Cohesion on Social ... - SSPH+, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.ssph-journal.org/journals/international-journal-of-public-health/articles/10.3389/ijph.2025.1607414/full
24. SOCIAL COHESION - Resilient Cities Network, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://resilientcitiesnetwork.org/downloadable_resources/UR/Social-Cohesion-Handbook.pdf
25. Cohesion in Public Health - Number Analytics, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.numberanalytics.com/blog/cohesion-public-health-resilience
26. THE EFFECTS OF IMMIGRATION ON SOCIAL COHESION: A SOCIOLOGICAL EXAMINATION - IJRAR.org, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.ijrar.org/papers/IJRAR19D4424.pdf
27. Perth and Kinross Council Equality Mainstreaming Report 2025 to 2029, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/media/35952/Equality-Outcomes-and-Mainstreaming-Report/pdf/Equality_Mainstreaming_Report_2025-2029.pdf?m=1746017616140
28. Migrant Workers in Perth and Kinross - The Care Sector.pdf - Migration Scotland, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.migrationscotland.org.uk/uploads/user_contributed/Migrant%20Workers%20in%20Perth%20and%20Kinross%20-%20The%20Care%20Sector.pdf
29. The Contributions of Immigrants to American Culture - PMC - PubMed Central, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3856769/
30. Canada's Long-Standing Openness to Immigration Comes Under ..., accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/canada-immigration-policy-inflection-point
31. Seeking social cohesion between host communities and migrants - IOM, ONU Migración, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://lac.iom.int/en/blogs/seeking-social-cohesion-between-host-communities-and-migrants
32. Immigrant Integration and Disintegration in an Era of Exclusionary Nationalism, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.cmsny.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Immigrant-Integration-and-Disintegration.pdf
33. The Impact of Migration on Social Cohesion and Integration - Research Explorer - The University of Manchester, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://research.manchester.ac.uk/files/56718536/FULL_TEXT.PDF
34. Australian social cohesion under threat | Pearls and Irritations - John Menadue, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://johnmenadue.com/post/2025/01/australian-social-cohesion-under-threat/
35. Local Immigration Partnerships Handbook, accessed on July 26, 2025, http://p2pcanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/CIC-Local-Immigration-Partnerships-Handbook.pdf
36. Canada's Private Sponsorship of Refugees program: potential lessons for Australia, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.refugeecouncil.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/Canadian-PSR-paper-1708.pdf
37. Canada's private sponsorship program: Success, shortcomings, and policy solutions - Toronto Metropolitan University, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.torontomu.ca/content/dam/centre-for-immigration-and-settlement/tmcis/publications/workingpapers/2021_6_Martani_Ervis_Canadas_private_sponsorship_program_success_shortcomings_and_policy_solutions.pdf
38. Private sponsorship prefigured: religious groups and Canada's Cold War refugee policy - Oxford Academic, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://academic.oup.com/jrs/article/38/1/151/7685513
39. The role of private sponsorship on refugee resettlement outcomes: a mixed methods study of Syrians in a mid-sized city with a linguistic minority, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/1369183X.2024.2434054?af=R
40. Welcoming Communities - Immigration New Zealand, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.immigration.govt.nz/about-us/our-strategies-and-programmes/supporting-refugees-and-asylum-seekers/welcoming-communities/
41. Welcoming communities New Zealand programme – Key messages updated, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.mbie.govt.nz/dmsdocument/14033-welcoming-communities-new-zealand-programme-key-messages-updated
42. Evaluation of the Expanded Welcoming Communities Programme - Immigration New Zealand, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.immigration.govt.nz/assets/inz/about-us/what-we-do/welcoming-communities/resources-welcoming-communities/Expanded-welcoming-communities-programme-evaluation-report-v3.pdf
43. Welcoming Communities Pilot Programme - Final Evaluation Summary Report July 2017, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.mbie.govt.nz/dmsdocument/14030-welcoming-communities-pilot-programme-final-evaluation-summary-report-july-2017-june-2019-martin-jenkins
44. The Welcoming Communities Standard | Immigration New Zealand, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.immigration.govt.nz/about-us/what-we-do/welcoming-communities/the-welcoming-communities-standard
45. Community Hubs Australia Submission - Department of Home Affairs, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/reports-and-pubs/PDFs/multicultural-framework-review-public-anonymous-submissions/a-c/community-hubs-australia.PDF
46. Multiculturalism & Community Cohesion | Industry - Festival City Adelaide, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://industry.festivalcityadelaide.com.au/impacts/multiculturalism-community-cohesion/
47. Funding boost for Multicultural festivals and events, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://multicultural.nsw.gov.au/media-releases/funding-boost-for-multicultural-festivals-and-events/
48. National Multicultural Festival receives funding boost - Our Canberra - ACT Government, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.act.gov.au/our-canberra/latest-news/2023/june/national-multicultural-festival-receives-funding-boost
49. National Multicultural Festival returns with massive cultural and economic boost, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.cmtedd.act.gov.au/open_government/inform/act_government_media_releases/cheyne/2023/national-multicultural-festival-returns-with-massive-cultural-and-economic-boost
50. Migrant integration in Sweden - European Commission - Migration and Home Affairs, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://home-affairs.ec.europa.eu/policies/migration-and-asylum/migrant-integration/migrant-integration-hub/eu-countries-updates-and-facts/migrant-integration-sweden_en
51. Constructing the ``Good Citizen'': Discourses of Social Inclusion in Swedish Civic Orientation - Cogitatio Press, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.cogitatiopress.com/socialinclusion/article/download/7060/3413
52. How can municipalities make it easier for refugees and their relatives to find work?, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.vr.se/english/just-now/news/news-archive/2022-11-23-how-can-municipalities-make-it-easier-for-refugees-and-their-relatives-to-find-work.html
53. NEW IN THE CITY, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.gu.se/sites/default/files/2020-06/new-in-the-city_report2018.pdf
54. Full article: The making of 'good citizens': German courses for migrants and refugees, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02660830.2018.1453115
55. Social Integration in Germany: Challenges & Solutions - Vaia, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.vaia.com/en-us/explanations/german/german-social-issues/social-integration-in-germany/
56. 6.6 Social inclusion through education and training - National Policies Platform, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://national-policies.eacea.ec.europa.eu/youthwiki/chapters/germany/66-social-inclusion-through-education-and-training
57. Germany's Syrian Refugee Integration Experiment - The Century Foundation, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://tcf.org/content/report/germanys-syrian-refugee-integration-experiment/
58. 1 “Refugees welcome” – Refugee integration policies in Berlin Neukölln - https: //rm. coe. int, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://rm.coe.int/168048e623
59. www.pkc.gov.uk, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/15093/Population-and-the-Census#:~:text=Scotland's%20Census%202022%20estimated%20the,difference%20to%20the%20national%20ratio.
60. Labour Market Profile - Perth and Kinross - Nomis, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.nomisweb.co.uk/reports/lmp/la/1946157428/printable.aspx
61. Population and the Census - Perth & Kinross Council, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/15093/Population-and-the-Census
62. Demographic statistics Municipality of PERTH AND KINROSS - UrbiStat, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://ugeo.urbistat.com/AdminStat/en/uk/demografia/dati-sintesi/perth-and-kinross/363/4
63. Perth and Kinross Child Poverty Action Report 2020 - Improvement ..., accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.improvementservice.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0019/24715/Perth-and-Kinross-LCPAR-2019_2020_FINAL.pdf
64. Perth & Kinross asked to commit to 'social contract' to eradicate poverty, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.scottishhousingnews.com/articles/perth-kinross-asked-to-commit-to-social-contract-to-eradicate-poverty
65. Local Child Poverty Action Report 2022/23 - Perth & Kinross Council, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/media/51794/Local-Child-Poverty-Action-Report-22-23-and-Action-Plan-23-24/pdf/Local_Child_Poverty_Action_Report_and_Local_Child_Poverty_Action_Plan__1.0_Submitted.pdf?m=1697449507137
66. People and Culture Strategy: Our operating context - Perth & Kinross ..., accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/24668/People-and-Culture-Strategy-Our-operating-context
67. Perth and Kinross Council Equality Mainstreaming Report 2025 to ..., accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/24608/Perth-and-Kinross-Council-Equality-Mainstreaming-Report-2025-to-2029
68. JOURNAL - Perth & Kinross Council, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/media/44739/Perth-Kinross-Economic-Journal-Migration-since-the-Brexit-vote-Summer-2019-update/pdf/EcJ_Migration_Briefing_Summer_2019.pdf?m=637026792281700000
69. Perth & Kinross Council Annual Performance Report, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/media/48777/Annual-Performance-Report-2020-21/pdf/2021141_-_Corporate_APR_2021_CLIENT.pdf?m=637697328773270000
70. Community empowerment - Perth & Kinross Council, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/21726/Community-empowerment
71. TSI (Perth & Kinross): Home, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.thirdsectorpk.org.uk/
72. About Us - TSI (Perth & Kinross), accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.thirdsectorpk.org.uk/about-us/
73. PKAVS | Charity Supporting People in Perth & Kinross, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.pkavs.org.uk/
74. Perth and Kinross Association of Voluntary Service Ltd (PKAVS) - Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.alliance-scotland.org.uk/blog/our_members/perth-and-kinross-association-of-voluntary-service-ltd-pkavs/
75. Independent Advocacy Perth and Kinross - Scottish Refugee Council, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://scottishrefugeecouncil.org.uk/places/independent-advocacy-perth-and-kinross/
76. Child poverty action in Perth and Kinross, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.pkc.gov.uk/article/22226/Child-poverty-action-in-Perth-and-Kinross
77. rth and Kinross based organisation working with a large cross section of our local communities, it is clear from our beneficiaries that they are unsure which messaging is to be adhered to; whether they should be abiding by the policies and strategies outli - UK Parliament Committees, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/7504/html/
78. Diversity, migration and social cohesion – Parliament of Australia, accessed on July 26, 2025, https://www.aph.gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_departments/Parliamentary_Library/Research/Issues_and_Insights/48th_Parliament/Diversitymigrationandsocialcohesion